Dark Meat Vs White Meat: Which One Is Better
Now that you’ve got a basic understanding of where the terms dark meat and white meat come from, let’s put these two types of poultry beak to beak on the following potential benefits:
Bottom line: If you’re are looking to cut calories and fat, chicken breast may help you cut a few calories. However, chicken thigh is a better source of healthy fats, iron, niacin, riboflavin and zinc.
Is Grilled Chicken Good For Cholesterol
Besides, is Grilled Chicken bad for cholesterol?
The Effect of White Meat on Cholesterol. One small, grilled, skinless chicken breast contains around 100 milligrams of cholesterol an amount that can add roughly 0.13 mmol/L to your cholesterol level! Animal products also contain saturated fat which causes our livers to manufacture even more cholesterol.
Also, which meat has the lowest cholesterol? To lower your blood cholesterol level, choose only the leanest meats, poultry, fish and shellfish.
- Choose chicken and turkey without skin or remove skin before eating.
- Some fish, like cod, have less saturated fat than either chicken or meat.
Similarly, it is asked, can you eat chicken if you have high cholesterol?
If you have high cholesterol, you should talk with your doctor about what you eat, including meat. There are good, lean choices. For example, you can consider chicken or turkey breasts without skin pork tenderloin or beef round, sirloin, or tenderloin.
Does Chicken increase LDL cholesterol?
In 2015, the U.S. Dietary Guidelines were updated to remove a restriction on cholesterol consumed in food, as it had little effect on our LDL levels. For instance, chickens store fat primarily under the skin, and chicken thighs are higher in fat and cholesterol than breast meat.
Here are some of the best morning foods for improving your numbers.
Study: Red And White Meat Might Have Equal Effects On Blood Cholesterol
In a study that could debunk years of conventional wisdom, researchers are reporting that red meat and white meat might have equal effects on blood cholesterol. The findings suggest that factors other than saturated fat may better explain the long-touted link between red meat consumption and heart disease. The study also showed that plant proteins are healthier for blood cholesterol levels than both red and white meat.
The study is one of the first detailed comparisons of the effects of different sources of dietary proteins on blood cholesterol. It evaluated changes in the participants blood cholesterol levels after eating diets containing high levels of proteins from either lean red meat, lean white meat, or non-meat sources . Participants included 113 healthy men and women between 21-65 years old. They consumed each of the three high-protein diets for four weeks in random order, and the researchers tested blood cholesterol levels after each dietary type.
The researchers found that consuming high levels of saturated fat was associated with an increase in blood cholesterol, regardless of meat type, and that both types of meat protein resulted in higher blood cholesterol than the non-meat diets. The study, called the APPROACH trial , appeared in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. It was supported by the NHLBI and the NIH National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences.
Don’t Miss: Does Shrimp Has Cholesterol
If You’ve Given Up Steak For Chicken Breast It May Not Be Helping Your Cholesterol As Much As You Thought
A grilled chicken breast sounds way healthier than a juicy steak, but it turns out that may not be the case. Researchers at the Childrens Hospital Oakland Research Institute set out to determine which types of meat raise cholesterol, and while its certainly not one of the 10 worst foods for your cholesterol, chicken tied with red meat for its effects.
The study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, analyzed the effects of red meat, white meat and plant-based protein sources on cholesterol levels. Healthy adults between the ages of 21 and 65 were assigned to groups in which they were allowed to red meat, white meat and plant-based protein, each for a four-week period. The order of the proteins was random for each group. The results surprised the researchers, they said in a press release.
When we planned this study, we expected red meat to have a more adverse effect on blood cholesterol levels than white meat, but we were surprised that this was not the casetheir effects on cholesterol are identical when saturated fat levels are equivalent, said Ronald Krauss, MD, study author and director of atherosclerosis research at the Childrens Hospital Oakland Research Institute.
Which Is Better For Cholesterol Fried Chicken Or Lean Steak
And, it also suggests that the way in which meats are prepared is also very important, whereby lean steaks or pork may be substituted for poorly prepared options like fried chicken, which combines present cholesterol with cooking methods that add saturated fat. Not all types of meat are good choices for a cholesterol diet.
Also Check: Is Pasta Bad For Your Cholesterol
When It Comes To Cholesterol Levels White Meat May Be No Better Than Red Meat And Plant
- By Katherine D. McManus, MS, RD, LDN, Contributor
A study published recently in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition sparked interest when it reported that red and white meat have a similar effect on low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, which is associated with increased heart disease risk. You may conclude, Well, if chicken is just as bad for my cholesterol as red meat, I may as well order that hamburger.
But lets examine the study more closely before drawing any conclusions.
Opt For Skinless Chicken
Although chicken is usually considered to be a good low-fat meat choice, how you cook it and serve it makes all the difference. For example, one chicken leg with the skin still on has more fat and saturated fat than a hamburger. Remember that removing the skin will help reduce the overall fat content, King says. Indulge in a fried chicken leg once in a while and stick to the grilled or baked chicken.
If you leave the skin on poultry or bread and deep-fry it, you turn it into an unhealthy, cholesterol-spiking food. Also, remember that dark poultry meat has more fat than white meat. When making chicken choices, opt for skinless and skip the dark meat.
Recommended Reading: What Affects Ldl
Get Cnn Health’s Weekly Newsletter
every Tuesday from the CNN Health team.
We do not need to see the study results âas a white or black issue,â she said. Meat, whether red or white, does not need to be banished from everyoneâs diet. While nutritionists make recommendations for the whole public, each individual is unique in nutritional needs.
âThe take-home message is there is no need to put a label of restricted or forbidden on red meat,â said Romo-Palafox. âMake sure you are choosing the leanest meats possible. If you can adopt a meatless Monday, why not? That might help you balance your risk.â
What Did The Study Find
Some participants dropped out along the way, so in the end researchers had results from 113 participants.
Blood concentrations of LDL cholesterol and apoB were lower following the plant protein diet period, compared to both the red and white meat periods. This was independent of whether participants were on a background diet of high- or low-saturated fat.
There was no statistically significant difference in the blood fat levels of those eating red meat compared to those eating white meat.
Eating a diet high in saturated fat led to significant increases in blood levels of LDL cholesterol, apoB, and large LDL particles compared with a background diet low in saturated fat.
So, all the dietary protein sources as well as the level of saturated fat intake had significant effects on total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, non-HDL cholesterol, and apoB levels.
Don’t Miss: How Does Cheerios Help Lower Cholesterol
What The Study Found
Led by researchers at Childrens Hospital Oakland Research Institute , the study looked at about 100 healthy men and women aged 21 to 65 over a four-year timespan. Participants were assigned to four-week cycles of eating either a high-saturated or low-saturated fat diet, with different tests of red meat, white meat, and plant-based protein sources like beans and legumes.
Expecting a surge mainly in the red-meat group, they were surprised to find that effects on cholesterol were identical in the white-meat group, according to study senior author Ronald Krauss, M.D., director of atherosclerosis research at CHORI.
On average, LDL cholesterolthe bad kindwere about 5 to 6 percent higher on each of the meat diets compared to the non-meat diet.
This could translate to a several percent higher heart disease risk, he told Runners World. However, there was a wide range of variation in response, so the clinical effect could be greater for some. In general, the takeaway here is that if you want to control blood cholesterol levels, diets with a high proportion of plant protein are to be preferred to those with high amounts of either red meat or white meat.
Featurehealth Matters: The Truth About Red Meat
Researchers said that the findings may not affect most people who arenât at high risk for heart disease. When participantsâ diets were low in saturated fat, the rise in LDL was minimal regardless of whether they ate chicken or lean red meat. But for the person actively trying to bring down high levels of LDL cholesterol, researchers said, it may be worth cutting back on both red and white meats, and relying more on plant proteins.
Red meat is a source of high-quality protein, zinc, iron and vitamin B12, but most nutritionists agree that it is best to choose a lean cut in a modest portion for optimal health benefits. The positives of having red or white meat can be canceled out if too much saturated fat, from any source, is included in ones diet.
Previous evidence shows that fatty red meat is a prime source of artery-clogging saturated fat, a factor associated with heart disease. And two studies published last year showed that people who eat red meat but not vegetarians or people who eat only white meat such as chicken have higher levels in the blood of a chemical called TMAO, which has been linked to higher heart disease risk.
The researchers cautioned against demonizing any food based on one study. âPeople often get the impression that if something raises cholesterol, it should be eliminated,â Krauss said. âI donât want people to get too focused on an all or nothing approach.â
- By Katherine D. McManus, MS, RD, LDN, Contributor
Read Also: Do Egg Beaters Have Cholesterol
Nutrition Comparison Of Salmon And Cooked Chicken Breast
- Jump to:
For a quick recap of significant nutrients and differences in salmon and chicken breast:
- Both chicken breast and salmon are high in calories, potassium and protein.
- For omega-3 fatty acids, salmon has more dha, epa and dpa than chicken breast.
- Salmon has more Vitamin B12.
- Salmon is an excellent source of Vitamin D.
Donât Miss: Why Is Shrimp So High In Cholesterol
Liver Eggs And Muffins Can Be Part Of A Heart Healthy Diet If You Know What To Watch Out For
You don’t have to be a nutritionist to know that you shouldn’t eat fries and fried chicken on a regular basis. They’re loaded with sodium and saturated fat and a diet high in saturated fat and trans fat can raise blood cholesterol levels, putting you at risk for heart disease, according to the American Heart Association .
Many foods that come from animals like meat and fat-containing dairy products contain saturated fat, while baked goods and fast food pack in trans fat, too. Because LDL cholesterol levels in particular can be too high on a high-saturated-fat diet, the AHA recommends that saturated fat make up no more than 5 to 6 percent of your total calories. On a diet of 2,000 calories a day, no more than 120 should come from saturated fat. Thats 11 to 13 grams of saturated fat per day at most.
Its worth noting that the thinking has changed about what increases cholesterol in the body. For example, previous dietary guidelines recommended consuming no more than 300 milligrams of dietary cholesterol per day. But in 2015, those guidelines changed, and there is now no specific recommendation limiting the amount of cholesterol that should be consumed through food. Thats because research has shown dietary cholesterol itself isnt harmful and actually doesnt contribute to increased levels of cholesterol in the body. Rather, the real culprits are saturated fat, trans fat, and added sugars.
Don’t Miss: Does Egg Beaters Have Yolk
When It Comes To Cholesterol White Meat May Not Be Better Than Red Meat
For as far back as many of us can remember, doctors and health experts have recommended eating white meat, such as chicken, instead of red meat if we wanted to control our cholesterol levels. This advice was reinforced by the poultry industry, well-known and respected nutritionists, research institutions and even the government!
One result of all these recommendations was U.S. consumption of poultry increased dramatically over the past several decades to where it surpassed beef consumption. Even pork producers tried jumping on this bandwagon when they launched their Pork, the Other White Meat marketing campaign some years back .
It now turns out that this recommendation may have been wrong and that any meat, regardless of where it comes from, may be bad for your cholesterol.
The researchers did caution that the study did not include fish nor grass-fed beef, and that additional investigation is required. They also acknowledged that these results contradict current guidelines but noted that there has never been a comprehensive study that compared red, white meat and plant proteins and their links to cholesterol.
Healthier Eating to Manage Cholesterol
Again, its fine to heave meat both red and white but in moderation. Just be sure to watch your portion sizes and include plenty of fresh vegetables, nuts, fresh fruit, legumes, and fish in your diet. And, of course, minimize processed foods, alcohol, added sugars and empty carbs.
Enjoy your healthy life!
How Should We Interpret The Results
Although the test diets only lasted four weeks each, this study is important. Its rare to see intervention studies that directly compare eating different types of meat and sources of protein and the impact on heart-disease risk factors. This is partly due to the challenge and expense of providing the food and getting people to follow specific diets.
Most studies to date have been cohort studies where people are categorised based on what they eat, then followed up for many years to see what happens to their health.
There are a few things to keep in mind with this study. First, the researchers used the leanest cuts of both red and white meats, and removed all visible fat and skin. If participants were eating fatty meat, we may have seen different results.
The significant variation in breaks between different diets may have also affected the results. Participants with a longer break would have had more time for their blood cholesterol levels to change, compared to those with shorter breaks.
Finally, in reporting their results, it would have been better to include all 177 participants who began the study. People who drop out often have different health characteristics and leaving them out may have biased results.
This short-term study does not provide evidence that choosing lean white meat over red meat is either better or worse for your health.
Read Also: Tuna Fish Cholesterol
Cholesterol Consumption And Healthy Diets
Despite its important role in the body, dietary cholesterol has typically been limited because of the association between cholesterol levels and disease. The previous edition of the Dietary Guidelines for Americanslimited recommended cholesterol intake to a total of 300 milligrams per day. This amount of cholesterol is equivalent to about:
- 5ounces of shrimp.
- Twosmall- to medium-sized eggs .
- 10.5ounces of chicken thighs.
- 19ounces of salmon.
However, the current Dietary Guidelines for Americans no longer limits your daily cholesterol intake. This is because dietary cholesterol is no longer thought to affect most people’s blood cholesterol.
According to the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, the dietary cholesterol you eat isn’t what usually raises the cholesterol levels in your blood. Instead, the biggest influence on your blood cholesterol levels comes from the types of fats and carbohydrates you consume in your diet. The American Heart Association recommends limiting foods that are rich in saturated and trans fats, because these are believed to directly influence your blood cholesterol levels.
Read more:9 Foods That Do Not Raise Cholesterol
White Meat Has Same Effect As Red Meat On Cholesterol Levels
The study found that LDL cholesterol was significantly higher after consuming the red meat and white meat diets, compared with the non-meat diet. This result was found regardless of whether the diet was high or low in saturated fat, though the high-saturated fat diets had a larger harmful effect on LDL cholesterol levels than the low-saturated fat diets. High-density lipoprotein cholesterol was unaffected by the protein source.
Though striking, the study has a number of limitations. The size of the study, 113 participants, was small the duration was short and there was a relatively high participant dropout rate. The study also did not include processed meats such as sausage, cold cuts, or bacon, which are known to be particularly harmful for heart health, or grass-fed beef, which is often touted as a healthier red meat option.
Recommended Reading: Canned Tuna Cholesterol