Heart Beat: Shellfish For The Heart
Fish is good for the heart, especially fatty fish like salmon and sardines. What about shellfish? Shrimp, lobster, clams, scallops, crayfish, and the like deliver smaller amounts of heart-healthy omega-3 fats than finfish. They also tend to be higher in cholesterol. A study from the Medical University of South Carolina suggests that shellfish certainly aren’t bad for the heart. But they may not offer the same protection against cardiac arrest and coronary artery disease as finfish.
The researchers came to this conclusion by looking at the onset of heart disease in the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities study. People who ate shellfish at least once a week were just as likely to have had a heart attack, needed a procedure to open or bypass blocked arteries, or died of a heart condition as those who ate shellfish only a few times a month and those who never ate shellfish .
To continue reading this article, you must log in.
- Research health conditions
- Prepare for a doctor’s visit or test
- Find the best treatments and procedures for you
- Explore options for better nutrition and exercise
What Are The Effects Of High Cholesterol
Cholesterol is a fat-like waxy substance that is found in the blood and cells. The body needs cholesterol to make the cell membranes, vitamin D, hormones and digestive fluids. It is vital for the normal functioning of the body, but high levels of cholesterol can be bad for the heart, blood vessels and pancreas. A simple blood test called a lipid profile or cholesterol screening can determine cholesterol levels.
Levels and ranges of cholesterol
Total cholesterol level:
Shellfish Are Low In Cholesterol
There seems to be conflicting information on the relationship between consuming shellfish and cholesterol. What does the latest research show? If shellfish is a high-cholesterol food, how much is too much?
For years, dietitians counseled people to avoid foods high in cholesterol. The theory was that eating cholesterol would raise cholesterol in the blood. As a result, many avoided eggs and shellfish, even though there was little, if any, data to suggest that such foods posed a problem.
There was a flaw with this advice, however. The old tests that were used to determine that shellfish was high in cholesterol were inaccurate. Clams, lobster, mussels and crab contain relatively little cholesterol. Even shrimp is not considered worrisome anymore.
Eating cholesterol-rich foods, such as eggs, does not necessarily raise cholesterol . In one study, people ate lots of red meat and eggs with almost no starch. Their bad LDL cholesterol did not go up, and their triglycerides actually down .
You recently wrote about using sugar for slow-healing wounds and bedsores. As a nurse, I learned years ago that the best way to use this home remedy is to make a thick paste of antibiotic ointment and sugar and pack the wound with it. Old wives tale or not, it works.
Another objected to our terminology: Using sugar for bedsores is not a wives tale. I have been a registered nurse for 45 years. When I was a student, it was very common practice to use sugar packs.
Don’t Miss: How Long Should You Wait Between Cholesterol Tests
Mollusks Oyster Pacific Raw
The full nutrition content, RDA percentages and levels for Mollusks, oyster, Pacific, raw should be considered along with the cholesterol content. This food profile is part of our list of food and drinks under the general group Finfish and Shellfish Products.Other important and cholesterol related nutrients are Calories, Protein, Fat and Carbohydrate. For this 100g serving in your diet, the amount of Calories is 81 kcal , the amount of Protein is 9.45 g , the amount of Fat is 2.3 g and the amount of Carbohydrate is 4.95 g . The nutritional content and facts for 100g, which includes Calories, Protein, Fat and Carbohydrate is shown in the RDA chart below as percentages of the recommended daily allowance along with the cholesterol levels in oysters.
Our proprietary nutritional density score gives a nutritional value out of 100 based on 9 different vitamins, minerals and macro nutrients. Mollusks, oyster, Pacific, raw has a nutritional value score of 17 out of 100.Comparing the cholesterol content and the nutritional density in 100g for Mollusks, oyster, Pacific, raw We class this as a high cholesterol content item.In terms of overall nutritional value we class this as an item with a medium nutritional density value.
Is The Cholesterol In Oysters Bad
QUESTION: My friend told me that oysters are high in cholesterol? Is it bad or good cholesterol? ANSWER: Hi, According to the last studies, oysters are classified as very healthful food. The explanation of this is kept in the amount of minerals, vitamins and the low amount of cholesterol and fatty acids in their meat. When you have low amount of fats and cholesterol in some food, this food is good for you, because it does not stimulate the production of bad cholesterol. However, you have to know that you might eat high amounts of fats or/and cholesterol when you have oyster meals. This is especially true when you bake the oysters with extra oil for example. Therefore, the best way to cook oysters is to boil them in salt water but be careful of extra salt too.The other good fact in meals made with oysters is the great amount of vitamins in them, especially vitamins of group B, C and E, which are considered as antioxidants. That means that they are cleaning up your organism from bad ions and molecules, which can damage you. In purpose to preserve the amount of vitamins in oyster you have to cook them in a specific way. Below you will find a special recipe to prepare a healthy oyster meal, which is low in cholesterol and with all the vitamins.
Don’t Miss: Tuna Good For Cholesterol
Benefits And Dangers Of Oysters
In addition to protein and omega-3s, oysters provide a variety of nutrients your body needs to function properly. Vitamin B12 and minerals like phosphorus, potassium, zinc and magnesium are just a few to mention.
The downside is that oysters are typically served raw or fried. Eating them raw comes with the risk of food poisoning. A type of bacteria called Vibrio vulnificus is often the cause of serious oyster-related illnesses.
If you have a compromised immune system from something like cancer, HIV/AIDS or pre-existing illnesses, youre considered high-risk and should cook oysters before eating.
How you cook oysters matters too. Deep-fried oysters, as well as those cooked in butter, are much higher in fat than steamed or boiled varieties. Frying oysters will increase the amount of fat, including saturated fat.
Even if eating high-cholesterol foods wont negatively impact your health, fat from unhealthy cooking methods can. As with all things, moderation is key.
Recommended Reading: Does Tuna Have Good Or Bad Cholesterol
Highest Amount Of Cholesterol Per Serving
Please remember that the above gives an accurate value in 100g for high cholesterol foods in your diet. For example 100g of Mollusks, oyster, Pacific, raw contains 50 mg of cholesterol. However, there are other factors to consider when you are assessing your nutritional requirements. You should also take into account portion sizes when you are considering the cholesterol nutritional content.
The food with the highest cholesterol content per typical serving is Mollusks, oyster, eastern, wild, raw which contains 99.2 mg in 1 cup . The percentage of the recommended daily value for this serving is 50 %. For this serving the Calories content is 126.48 kcal, the Protein content is 14.16 g, the Fat content is 4.24 g and the Carbohydrate content is 6.75 g.
Also Check: Does Shrimp Have High Cholesterol
Cholesterol And The Great Egg Debate
One source of confusion has long been eggs. A typical egg contains about 200 milligrams of cholesterol, but only 1.5 grams of saturated fat. When researchers first linked high bloodcholesterol levels to heart disease, eggs got a bad rap.
But there’s never been good evidence that eggs are a major factor in high blood cholesterol levels or a contributing cause of heart disease.
In fact, when researchers at Harvard Medical School analyzed data from almost 120,000 men and women, they found that eating the equivalent of an egg a day did not increase the risk of heart disease or stroke. A more recent Harvard Medical School study, published in 2008, also found that otherwise healthy men could eat up to seven eggs a day with little risk. The only danger showed up in men with diabetes, which is known to increase heart disease risk.
Indeed, studies suggest that only about 30% of people are particularly susceptible to the effects of dietary cholesterol on blood cholesterol levels.
And overall, the effects of dietary cholesterol are relatively small compared with saturated fat and trans fats.
In a review of studies in which volunteers were fed eggs, researchers found that lowering the amount of dietary cholesterol by 100 milligrams a day resulted in only a 1% reduction in blood cholesterol levels. Replacing saturated fat with unsaturated fat had a much more beneficial effect on cholesterol.
Content Per Typical Serving Size 1 Medium
To give 100% of the RDA, 7.7 servings of the typical serving size 1 medium give the complete RDA. In terms of the gram weight and total content for this serving the Calories content is 40.5 kcal, the Protein content is 4.73 g, the Fat content is 1.15 g and the Carbohydrate content is 2.48 g. The percentages are shown below in the cholesterol chart, for the typical serving of cholesterol and the related and important nutritional values.
You May Like: Ldl Cholesterol Effects
Buying Shrimp And Scallops
When shopping for shrimp, look for:
- Flesh that’s transparent, not cloudy
- A sweet scent of fresh seawater
- Fresh-caught or frozen, wild-caught
If a package of shrimp smells fishy or like ammonia or bleach, do not use it.
Scallops in grocery stores are usually wet-packed. That means they’re shucked on a boat and put in cold water to preserve them longer. They should be:
- White
- Slightly moist
- Not shredded or mangled
Packaging should be firmly closed and not allow for any odor to escape. Much like shrimp, they should not smell fishy or have an ammonia- or bleach-like odor.
In general, look for shellfish that are clean, covered in ice, and smell like the ocean. If they have shells, like clams or oysters, the shells should be closed.
Are There Any Risks In Eating High Cholesterol Seafoods
Studies have shown that there is no link between dietary cholesterol and heart diseases. At least in the general population.
What do I mean by this?
The research that was conducted, showed no signs that people who consumed high levels of cholesterol through animal products were at any higher risk of heart disease. This included people that consume large amounts of cholesterol in their diet through animal products.
However, there are some people that are considered as hyper-responders or non-compensators, these people were more vulnerable to heart diseases after consuming food that had high dietary cholesterol.
So, if you dont know which one you are, it is better to be cautious about it and stay on the safer side rather than going YOLO.
If you are worried about heart diseases, then you should be focusing on the LDL to HDL ratio. This is the most important thing that will predict whether you will suffer from a heart disease in the near future or not. Make sure you ask your doctor what ratio is healthy for your age and body type and whether you should do something about it.
Recommended Reading: Beer Increases Cholesterol
Dietary Cholesterol And Heart Disease
Dietary cholesterol is only found in animal-based products. This includes meat and seafood, egg yolks and dairy products, including milk. It was once believed that eating foods high in cholesterol would raise the cholesterol levels in your body an increase your risk of cardiovascular disease. However, studies have not shown any link between dietary cholesterol and cardiovascular disease, notes Dr. Ghada Soliman in her review published in the June 2018 edition of Nutrients.
The 2010 Dietary Guidelines recommended limiting cholesterol to 300 milligrams per day. However, due to the lack of evidence that dietary cholesterol has negative health effects, this recommendation has been removed from the USDA’s current 2015 edition of the Dietary Guidelines for Americans.
There is a correlation between saturated fats and cardiovascular disease and saturated fats have been shown to increase your LDL cholesterol levels, advises Colorado State University Extension. Since many foods that are high in saturated fats are also high in cholesterol, it is a good idea to limit your intake of these foods. The 2015 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends getting less than 10 percent of your calories from saturated fats.
Read more: The Truth About How Your Diet Affects Your Cholesterol
The Effects Of Dietary Cholesterol
In theory, it makes sense that dietary cholesterol could raise the levels of cholesterol in your blood, thereby putting you at greater risk for heart disease. According to a research paper published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition in August 2015, saturated and trans fats, not dietary cholesterol, might be to blame for the increase in LDL levels.
Animal products tend to be higher in saturated fat and dietary cholesterol than plant-based foods. In other words, someone with high dietary cholesterol intake probably eats a lot of saturated fat. In that case, limiting saturated fat should be a priority.
One oyster has about 25 calories, 3 grams of protein, 1 gram of carbohydrates and less than 1 gram of fat. Of that small amount of fat, only 0.25 grams come from saturated fat. Egg cholesterol, by comparison, is 9.9 milligrams per serving .
To put that into perspective, three oysters would total 0.6 grams of saturated fat. One serving of steak , on the other hand, has over 5 grams of saturated fat. That makes oysters a healthier alternative.
Read Also: Is Tuna Bad For Cholesterol
Shellfish Is High In Dietary Cholesterol
Shellfish is linked in many peoples minds to high cholesterol, so a lot of people avoid it if their cholesterol level is elevated. Is this action justified?
Simply stated, shrimp are high in cholesterol. 100 grams of shrimp yields about 190 mg of cholesterol, more than half the recommended daily allowance. However, blaming shrimp for high cholesterol counts is a very simplistic response, based on a misunderstanding of how we get high cholesterol levels.
Beyond Cholesterol: Saturated Fat And Trans Fat
What’s a food shopper to do? Even though cholesterol isn’t the chief villain, it’s still worth glancing at how much a packaged food contains. The official advice from the American Heart Association and other groups is to limit your total daily intake to less than 300 milligrams.
But while checking cholesterol numbers, also take a look at the saturated fat, which has a much bigger impact on raising cholesterol levels. Most nutritionists say a healthy diet should get no more than 7% of calories from saturated fat.
Trans fats may be even more dangerous because they raise LDL, or “bad” cholesterol levels and lower HDL, the “good cholesterol” at the same time.
Fortunately, trans fats, which are found in partially hydrogenated oils, are being phased out of many packaged foods, so they pose less of a danger. Still, if you eat a lot of processed foods, you may still be consuming more than you should.
Foods can call themselves “trans-free” as long as they contain less than half a gram of trans fats per serving. To find out whether a food has trans fats, check the ingredient label for partially hydrogenated oils.
You May Like: Do Ritz Crackers Have Fiber
Cholesterol Levels In Shellfish
Shellfish have a bad but perhaps unfair reputation as vehicles for dietary cholesterol. Excessive dietary cholesterol is notoriously linked to cardiovascular disease risk, even though saturated and trans fats have a stronger effect on raising blood cholesterol levels. Though shellfish do have a high cholesterol content, this shouldn’t discourage you from eating them as they are also a rich source of many beneficial nutrients.
Risks And Benefits Of Seafood
Adding seafood to your diet may actually help improve your blood cholesterol levels. A study published in the November 2017 edition of Atherosclerosis found that consuming oily fish increased the goodHDL cholesterol levels in the blood.
Seafood is a good protein source full of nutrients. It is especially known for having high omega-3 fatty acid content including both EPA and DHA, which decreases the risk of heart disease. The USDA recommends that adults eat eight ounces of seafood each week. Seafood may contain the heavy metal mercury, however, the health benefits of fish outweigh the risks of mercury consumption, advises the USDA.
Some low-mercury seafood options include:
-
Atlantic mackerel and Pacific mackerel
-
Salmon
Recommended Reading: Does Shrimp Raise Cholesterol
Read Also: Salmon Roe Cholesterol
Beneficial Nutrients In Shellfish
Shellfish, in addition to having lower overall fat and saturated fat than other meats, contain high-quality protein and are good sources of iron, zinc, copper, and vitamin B-12. These nutrients can be hard to acquire from plant foods, so people who eat seafood but no meat may benefit from eating shellfish. Keep in mind that shellfish are often prepared with lots of butter or deep-fried, which can adversely affect cholesterol levels. Using lighter vinaigrettes or limiting fatty sauces can be a heart-friendly alternative.
High In Vitamins And Minerals
Oysters are a good source of vitamin B12, iron, zinc, copper, manganese and selenium. Vitamin B12 is important for the formation of red blood cells, metabolism and the maintenance of the central nervous system. Iron is involved in oxygen transport and metabolism and the synthesis of neurotransmitters. Zinc is required for immune response, cell division, cell growth, wound healing and the breakdown of carbohydrates. Copper is a component of several enzymes and is needed for the regulation of gene expression, connective tissue formation, cellular metabolism and the absorption, storage, and metabolism of iron. Manganese is needed for antioxidant function, metabolism, bone development and wound healing. Selenium is essential in several metabolic pathways.
Read Also: Shrimp And Cholesterol